Msr Xgk Ex Stove Vs Whisperlite

We didn t think noise would be a point in comparison for fuel stoves but it is.

Msr xgk ex stove vs whisperlite.

The stove remained relatively unchanged for years. From left to right the all around er msr whisperlite international the gourmet cooking msr dragonfly and the burly snow melting machine the msr xgk ex. The msr dragonfly is loud like really loud. Msr knew they created a quality product with the first generation whisperlite stove.

See stove instruction manual. In 2018 the whisperlite universal has received a few upgrades that have turned a solid reliable stove into a truly fantastic versatile powerhouse. In comparison the msr whisperlite sounds like a whisper. Black bear prepper discusses loud stove vs quiet stove boil times.

I will say this. It is your lightweight white gas stove. Thus one stove could perform all of the function of four current white gas stoves stoves dragonfly xgk ex whisp and internationale. It s almost not even possible to have a conversation when the dragonfly is in full blast.

If you know what this is what you need then go for it. Xgks are nice for alaska where you are spending a lot of time melting snow but unless you are planning on spending a lot of time there the whisperlite will get you by. Simmering with the whisperlite universal takes a few tricks like leaving a lot of air space in the fuel bottle and only pumping up the bottle with about 1 4 the normal amount of. Whisperlite will work as well as the xgk for most situations.

I have not used the simmerlite but have heard of its use in similar conditions to mine. If you want a great simple backpacking stove that is easy to maintain and easier to cook on than the xgk ex choose the msr whisperlite a great value at 89 95. The following tip applies to both models of the whisperlite stove the simmerlite stove and the windpro stove. Depending on where in the world you plan to use your stove the options may vary from what you re used to at home.